Skip to content

.454 Casull Vs .44 Magnum – Which Is Better?

There is a common topic among friend’s discussions. Which is the best, .454 Casull or .44 Magnum? Some say .454 Casull is 1.5 times powerful than the .44 Magnum. Others say .454 Casull is 2 times powerful. .454 has a higher velocity than .44 Magnum. .44 Magnum is easy and pleasant to use.

Are these specifications right? Is the .454 Casull more powerful than the .44Magnum? Maybe. And now you are confused. Don’t worry. We will clear your mind. We will give an overall idea on .454 Casull and .44 Magnum. You will be able to decide which is better. So, lets get to the comparison of .454 Casull vs .44 Magnum.

.454 Casull vs .44 Magnum

.454 Casull Overview

.454 Casull Overview

Dick Casull, Jack Fullmer, and Duane Marsh created this cartridge in 1958. You may understand, the name of .454 Casull has come from Dick Casull.

.454 Casull got its production started in 1997. This cartridge gets popular for its high velocity. It is a good cartridge for hunting and target shooting.

.44 Magnum Overview

.44 Magnum Overview

The .44 Magnum is specially made for rifles and revolvers. .44 Remington Magnum, 10.93×33mmR, and .44 Magnum are same large-bore cartridge.

Elmer Keith created the .44 Mag in 1954. And Smith & Wesson company started to produce this cartridge in 1955. Most people use this for hunting and target shooting.

.454 Casull Vs.44 Mag Breakdown

.454 Casull Vs. .44 Mag; Breakdown

Specs

Specs

In this part, we will talk about the size and shape of the Casull .454 and Magnum .44. The trajectory, velocity, energy, and recoil of a cartridge depends on the cartridge size. So, it is an important thing to the comparison between two cartridges.

The bullet diameter, neck diameter, base diameter, rim diameter, and rim thickness of .454 Casull is .452″ or 11.5 mm, .480″ or 12.2 mm, .480″ or 12.2 mm, .512″ or 13 mm, and .057″ or 1.4 mm respectively. The case length is 1.383″ or 35.1 mm. The overall length of Casull .454 is 1.77″ or 45 mm.

The bullet diameter, neck diameter, base diameter, rim diameter, and rim thickness of .454 Casull is .429″ or 10.9 mm, .457″ or 11.6 mm, .457″ or 11.6 mm, .514″ or 13.1 mm, and .060″ or 1.5 mm respectively. The case length is 1.285″ or 32.6 mm. The overall length of the .44 Mag is 1.61″ or 41 mm. The Casull .454 is slid bigger than the .44Mag.

Ballistic Power

The comparison remains incomplete without the ballistic power comparison. Most people only see the ballistic power of a cartridge before buying one.

Velocity

Velocity

The .454 Casull has 1900 ft/s, 1650 ft/s, 1600 ft/s, 1500 ft/s, and 1400 ft/s velocity for 240 gr (grain) or 16 g, 300 gr or 19g, 335 gr or 22 g, 360 gr or 23 g, and 400 gr or 26 g respectively. The velocity of .44 Magnum is 1180 ft/s, 1250 ft/s, and 1425 ft/s for 240 gr, 300 gr, and 340 gr respectively.

Muzzle Energy

Muzzle Energy

The .454 Casull has 1923 ft-lbs, 1813 ft-lbs, 1904 ft-lbs, 1800 ft-lbs, and 1741 for 240 gr (grain) or 16 g, 300 gr or 19g, 335 gr or 22 g, 360 gr or 23 g, and 400 gr or 26 g respectively.

The muzzle energy of .44 Magnum is 741 ft-lbs, 1041 ft-lbs, and 1533 ft-lbs for 240 gr, 300 gr, and 340 gr, respectively. The velocity and muzzle energy comparison says that .454 Casull has more ballistic power than .44 Mag. So, we can say .454 is a powerful cartridge than .44 Magnum.

Recoil

Recoil

Recoil is a imperative scale to compare between two cartridges. Recoil has effects on the accuracy of new shooters. But, professionals don’t have a big problem with recoil. Recoil depends on barrel size, gun, cartridge size, and velocity. If you shoot with a big barrel gun, you will face more recoil.

The .44 Mag has less recoil than  the .454 Casull. It is very tough to control .454 Casull. You have to hold the gun in the right ways. Because your hand can wretch for this high recoil. We face the high recoil for the velocity. It has 580 m/s velocities for 250 grains bullet.

Accuracy

Accuracy

Accuracy depends on recoil, velocity, wind, muzzle energy, and size. For professional shooters, recoil, velocity, or size don’t have big effects on their accuracy. They practice a lot. If you are a newbie shooter, these things will affect your accuracy.

.454 Casull has more recoil, more velocity, and more energy than .44 Mag. And .454 Casull is slightly bigger than .454 Casull. That’s why you will be able to shoot more accurately with .44 Magnum than .454. It would be best if you tried both of them. You will understand clearly which has more accuracy.

Uses Of .454 Casull

Uses Of .454 Casull

.454 Casull has higher muzzle energy in big grain bullets. That is why it is used for safety from beer. You also can use this cartridge for mid to large-level hunting.

Uses Of .44 Magnum

Uses Of .44 Magnum

.44 Magnum has a decent velocity. You can use this cartridge for hunting. Because it is made for hunting lovers. Sometimes, it can be used for self-defense. Though it isn’t a good choice for self-defense purposes.

Bottom Line

We don’t want to give you any statement. Because, if we give any statement, you will influence by our statement. That’s why we have given an overall idea on .454 Casull vs. .44 Magnum. We hope you can now decide which is best for you. I hope now you know about .454 Casull vs .44 Magnum. Don’t hesitate to inform us if you didn’t understand any part clearly.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *